The directive given to us for our first blog post was to play two console based games (the choices being Colossal Cave Adventure, NetHack and Rogue) and then to answer a series of questions about our experience.
Colossal Cave Adventure
Q 1. Which elements of the game did you find enjoyable?
A. The many varying answers/outcomes to the actions the player inputs is something I found particularly fun and interesting as not only does it show the level of story depth and creativity within the game but it provides massive play-back value; meaning the gamer gets good value and doesn't bore of the game as the experience changes with each play-through.
Q 2. Which elements of the game did you not find enjoyable?
A. Although it could be considered a vital part of the gaming experience, I often found it frustrating trying to find the right word or direction that the game was looking for in order to proceed.
Q 3. For those elements of the game which you did not enjoy, why do you think the
game has been designed in this way?
A. As the game’s lure is that of exploration and adventure, the designers probably wanted to make the player think about their location and the possible answers, along with providing a more challenging experience. Also it may have been impossibly difficult for the designers and rather boring for the player to have every input as a possible solution.
Q 4. At the time this game was originally released why do you think it was so popular?
A. The creativity and story potential is interesting even now, but I think the interactive capabilities are great, so the fact it was popular when released is no surprise. The effort put in to creating and constructing the game is clear, and the amount of versatility could be likened to that of modern-day games.
Q 5. How does the game attempt to compensate for the lack of graphics?
A. As the game doesn’t have any visual images at all, it is instead incredibly descriptive, which allows the player to still experience something rich is imagery.
Q 6. In terms of the ‘player experience’, does Colossal Cave Adventure offer any advantages over modern adventure games? Describe your views on this.
A. Many people may argue that players nowadays are supplied with games that have amazing graphics, but very little in story and substance. With Colossal Cave Adventures, the game has nothing fancy to fall back on and relies solely on the story and gameplay and offers massive playback value.
NetHack
Q 1. Which elements of the game did you find enjoyable?
A. The movement abilities as they make the gamer feel they have more freedom and the aspect of having a companion (in this case a kitten) follow your movements was rather fun. Also the character choice options were a nice touch; a very basic type of rpg customisation.
Q 2. Which elements of the game did you not find enjoyable?
A. The lack of direction given and help options (I often found myself lost without any instruction or guidance on what I was supposed to do next) was a point of frustration and I sometimes found the game a little repetitive (I didn't gain the same sense of adventure as I did from CCA).
Q 3. For those elements of the game which you did not enjoy, why do you think the
game has been designed in this way?
A. The gamer often can go in and out of the same room and encounter different objects/situations which means perhaps there is no need for guidance and the player is supposed to use their own initiative.
Q 4. At the time this game was originally released why do you think it was so popular?
A. The fact there is some visual gameplay for NetHack must have seemed quite advanced at the time, along with the control system. It’s fairly quick and fast paced, and with the interactive battles, it must have seemed rather exciting.
Q 5. Are there any elements of gameplay within NetHack which are not used in
modern role playing games? Describe your views on this.
A. Having not played all modern role playing games I can’t be completely sure on my answer, but I find the use of a companion rather rare at least and the fact that the companion interacts with monsters independently to be rather unique.
No comments:
Post a Comment