After reading the article on the massive theft on Eve I decided to do some research into virtual incidents and how they made an effect in the real world/people in it.
It wasn’t long until I came across a very interesting article entitled ‘A Rape in Cyberspace’ by Julian Dibbell. I spent a good while enthralled by it; the events that transpired were both fascinating and horrific.
The article centred around a startling event that occurred in the multiplayer computer game (or MUD) called LambdaMOO; a text based online virtual reality game, capable of having multiple users (players) connected at the same time.
The incident involved a player using a ‘voodoo doll’ subprogram, which allowed him to control other player avatars and have them do things against their will. These actions, which included describing sexual acts that character performed on each other, went far beyond the community norms to that point and continued for several hours.
The repercussions of this act on the virtual community were immense; they were interpreted as sexual violation of the avatars and provoked outrage amongst the LambdaMoo users, raising questions about the boundaries between the real word and virtual reality, and how the game should be governed in the future.
After the incident occurred numerous users posted comments about the emotional trauma that was caused by the player’s actions. One user, whose avatar was a victim of the ‘cyber-rape’ called the attacker’s voodoo doll activities ‘’a breach of civility’’ while in real life, ‘’post-traumatic tears were streaming down her face.’’ However, despite the strong emotions, including the fury voiced by many users on LambdaMoo, none were willing to punish the user behind the incident through real-life means, after all no ‘real’ crime had been committed, no bodies had touched, no real act of violence had taken place. This being said, the effect it had upon the victims was real; after all the attacker had violated their minds, and is not the mind part of the body?
One victim posted a request that the attacker player be ‘toaded’, a term meaning to delete the account of the user and their avatar; it was, in its purest form, a request for the avatar’s execution.
Three days after the event users of LambdaMoo arranged an online meeting which Dibbell (the Article’s author) attended, to deliberate what should be done about the user who caused the incident. The meeting lasted almost three hours, but no definite conclusions were made. After attending the meeting one of the master-programmers of the game decided on his own to terminate the user’s account. Additionally, upon his return from a business trip, LambdaMoo’s main creator, Pavel Curtis set up a system of petitions and ballots where anyone could put to popular vote anything requiring master-programmer (known as ‘wizardly’ in the game) powers for its application. Through this system LambdaMoo users put into place a ‘@boot’ command, which temporarily disconnects disruptive guest users from the server, as well as a number of other new features.
The fact that such an event could stir such emotion and make such an impact to the players of an online game, along with the changes to the game and the ‘community’ that was then build through the attack’s actions, are extraordinary.
The events described in the article made many people curious about the legal implications of online activity, including Lawrence Lessig, and the author of the article himself (who went on to teach cyberlaw as a Fellow at Stanford Law School Centre for the Internet and Society.)
After much thought over how such an event could cause such a reaction from the public, I have come to a simple conclusion; it doesn’t matter where or how the crime was committed, but the fact that it was committed at all.
With the subject matter of real-world rape being one of complete seriousness it may be difficult for some people to take ‘virtual rape’ as anything despicable at all, more so of a ‘joke’ and something the avatar victims shouldn’t take to heart, but the clear fact is the users of that online game were a community and some thought themselves protected from such actions.
With the subject matter of real-world rape being one of complete seriousness it may be difficult for some people to take ‘virtual rape’ as anything despicable at all, more so of a ‘joke’ and something the avatar victims shouldn’t take to heart, but the clear fact is the users of that online game were a community and some thought themselves protected from such actions.
Some might liken the incident to that of a hacker breaking into someone else’s computer and stealing information about them; but of course that is accountable as a real-life crime. The real-world community involved with the cyberrape had to debate with the law as to whether such a thing could be counted as an actual crime; with that kind of social and moral examination becoming something that changed the future of not just that game but the people involved with its creation and its users.