This week we focused on design, and the terminology used for certain aspects of gaming. Below I've identified and described some of these aspects in the two games I originally played and reviewed in my first blog.
Colossal Cave Adventure:
Colossal Cave Adventure:
Style of competition: Single Player Competition (Player vs. Environment)
Positive Feedback: The player receives feedback in the form of the items/actions taken having a direct effect on what they can do later in the game (for example there may be a lamp in a room, and if they take it they will be able to use it later to light their way, which then it turn reduces their risk of death) and then, as they progress through the game the further they get the more chances they have to pick up valuable items.
Boundaries: As the game has no graphics, the boundaries are not ‘visible’ but rather told to the player; they appear to be on a map and cannot go beyond what the map has sketched out.
Possible Outcomes: There is definitely more than one outcome in a game like Colossal Cave Adventure, and although there is a set map-path, the player can chose multiple ways to make their way around it.
Recuperation: The Player often has large periods of exploration before having to deal with a particularly dangerous/challenging situation.
Ethical Constraints (morality): There doesn’t seem to me any particular morality in Colossal Cave Adventures (for example, the first time I played I killed a bird, that I’m pretty sure I was supposed to catch! But the game allowed me to find a way around problems like that later on)
Turn based or real time: Although I don’t think the game could really be classed as either, if I had to choose I’d swing for Turn-Based – the game gives the player endless time to decide on the next action and the player can also hold large amounts of resources at any time.
Main sources of Fun: Narrative, Challenge, Discovery
Internal economy of the game: The game places items around the game that the player must pick up – though if they forget they can go back and get them or find another way around a situation – although there is no specific drain on the resources there isn’t an abundance of resources either.
Level of Challenges: The difficultly never really increases or decreases, but there is a definite hint that you should think back to previous interactions you’ve taken in order to work out what the best move should be.
Conciseness: As the game has no graphics it can’t ‘show’ the player where they are, so instead it tells them; something some players might find boring, but it also sets the scene for the action, whilst also giving the player specific details that might have a direct correlation to an upcoming challenge.
Emergence: There are hints of emergent gameplay; for example there are ways a player can use an object in more ways than the game might be directing them to.
NetHack:
Style of competition: Single Player Competition (Player vs. Environment)
Positive Feedback: The player receives feedback in the form of levelling up, and items received for defeating in-game monsters.
Boundaries: The boundaries include visible walls inside rooms, but also invisible walls when walking along the paths between rooms; keeping the player going from room to room.
Possible Outcomes: The game includes multiple paths/directions to take, not only in game, but with the choice of character/gender etc. that you pick out before you start playing.
Recuperation: The Player gets short periods of rest-bite, but due to the nature of the gameplay, and the ever-changing situation, the player can never be sure of how much time they will have to recuperate.
Ethical Constraints (morality): Net-Hack certainly has a direction to comply with the ‘plot’ of the game (more so than Colossal Cave Adventures) as the storyline is more complicated, and there is a stronger fantasy, RPG feel to it; though I have not played through the entire game so there may be later chances to ‘betray’ the storyline.
Turn based or real time: The game is certainly more Real time than Turn based, as the player can move constantly, and the in-game monsters move at their own pace.
Conciseness: The game doesn’t rely on description, and gives the player direct instructions/commands as they/in the moment they meet with the object of interaction; for example the moment they come in contact with a monster the game informs the player they just started a battle with said monster and let the player go on from there; informing them at each point of the battle what their actions are resulting to.
Level of Challenges: As the player levels up, the challenges in game also adjust to the new skill level of the player-character; leading the player to think more about their choices in battle and use of objects.
Sources of fun: Fellowship (with the kitten), challenge, fantasy
Internal economy of the game: The game allows the player to collect gold, along with other items within the game, which can then be used later, though there doesn’t seem to be any particular limit on the gold one character can handle there is certain a limit to the items one can collect (for example, if you miss an item to collect, you can’t always go back and collect the same item again). Also resources can be collected from battling monsters, though that involves risk of defeat/death.
No comments:
Post a Comment